Reducing restrictive practice: it’s always the right time to make a difference

A sign showing different ward names

Post Title

Forensic mental health units (sometimes referred to as secure units) provide a vital service in caring for people with severe mental health conditions who may be a risk to the safety of themselves or others.

Reducing the use of restrictive practices (such as inappropriate physical restraint or rapid tranquilisation) in these units poses a unique set of challenges. In this blog, we hear from HIN Project Manager Ayobola Chike-Michael, Expert by Experience, Igoche Ikwue and Ward Manager Toheeb Bawala about how a recent visit to a forensic ward provided proof that impactful interventions can still be implemented successfully in the face of significant operational pressures.

This is the latest in a series of reflective blogs about the Health Innovation Network’s involvement in local efforts to reduce restrictive practice based on the findings of a successful pilot led by the National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health. Find links to all our blogs here.

Ayo

An integral part of our reducing restrictive practice programme is to visit participating mental health wards to build relationships and support systematic quality improvement.  We have worked with ten wards across our region to enable shared learning, suggesting and supporting change ideas through codesign and coproduction with experts by experience and insights related to health inequalities.

One of the wards we have visited is Ruby Ward – a 10 bedded, female forensic ward. Although Ruby Ward was not the first mental health ward we have visited, visiting a forensic ward was a unique experience which offered valuable insights into the world of forensic mental health and challenges faced by both staff and service users.

As expected, there was a high level of security at the ward. This meant we passed through several checkpoints and adhered to strict rules before being allowed access to the unit. The ward itself was clean, well-maintained and staffed by a team of dedicated healthcare professionals led by Toheeb Bawala, the ward manager.

Delivering high-quality person-centred care on forensic wards is inherently more complex and potentially more challenging than other inpatient settings, and the Ruby Ward team also have to contend with limited physical space (although we were pleased to hear that the ward is moving to a more spacious location) and the current workforce pressures affecting mental health staffing levels. Although many mental health services are experiencing problems with recruitment and retention of staff, forensic units face particular challenges due to the high staff-to-service user ratio required to safely deliver this type of specialist care.

Despite these difficulties, we immediately noticed that the staff demonstrated a deep understanding of the unique needs and challenges faced by service users and they were committed to providing the best possible care and support.

We also discussed positive interventions that had worked to reduce restrictive practice in their environment. The ward manager Toheeb talked us through their collaborative daily planning exercises with service users; a simple but highly effective technique which they had found reduced conflict and created a calmer environment for everyone on the ward. Daily, staff engaged with all patients after their breakfast to co-plan their day. This helped staff with planning and gave service users a voice to express their own preferences.

Although the intervention itself was straightforward, coming to these arrangements needed flexibility on the part of staff to move away from previous protocols (such as more rigid weekly activity planning), working with service users to listen and adapt the approach taken to their care.

I was grateful to the staff for allowing us to visit at a time when pressures were so high, for showing us that a quality improvement philosophy can still make a difference to outcomes even when teams are exceptionally busy. It also served as a reminder to me of why support from the rest of the system for frontline teams is so important – sharing learnings and helping to catalyse service development.

Igoche

My reflections as an expert by experience remain fresh in my mind every day. I keep thinking about the best ways to improve mental health services in a more compassionate and humane way, while also ensuring safety.

My visit to Ruby Ward felt like diving into the unknown, and from the moment I began the series of security checks to enter, I knew it was different to anywhere we had visited as part of our project so far.

I believe that walking into such an environment and interacting with members of staff must be done in a person-centred way. My thought process focused on showing more compassion and kindness through communication to demonstrate that we are truly there to support, listen and learn.

One of the things that struck me was the physical space. We know that having the right physical environment is important for service user recovery and reduces the need for restrictive practice. Well-designed spaces can reduce stress and anxiety, promote social interaction and support a sense of normalcy and autonomy. They can also support the efforts of staff, for example designing clear sight lines throughout the unit so that service users can be monitored and situations can be identified early and de-escalated before restrictive practice becomes the only option.

Ruby Ward’s current setting included some recreational spaces and a gym, but it also had features that were less than optimal, such as a lack of natural light in some areas. The overall footprint of the unit is fairly small, meaning that personal space for service users could feel limited.

It was great to hear from Toheeb that the Ward will be moving to a more well-suited location. I am sure that this new space will make a real difference to service users and staff, and I think it is important to reflect on the commitment that it has taken to make this happen. Some interventions can be straightforward to implement – such as the daily planning exercises Ayo has discussed – but others may take months or even years of work to bring to fruition. It is important that we provide the practical support and knowledge required to help teams make changes of all sizes which can improve care.

My main takeaway from visiting the ward was that quality improvement support needs to be offered in a way which demonstrates kindness and compassion. Services such as forensic units care for extremely vulnerable people who are often very unwell. This is not easy work, especially when combined with external factors such as the shortage of mental health professionals across the NHS. We must recognise that the staff of these wards are striving to do the best they can in challenging circumstances, and that our efforts need to be led by love and humanity if we want to build relationships which will allow us to help them on their journey.

Toheeb

Ruby Ward is an extremely busy and complex environment to work in. We care for patients who can be very unwell and we operate with greater restrictions than many other services because we must maintain a secure environment.

As such, it is perhaps unsurprising that the staffing pressures affecting the whole mental health sector have had a particularly pronounced impact on forensic wards like ours.

Despite these challenges, I am proud of the quality of care we deliver and the spirit in which we deliver it.

The visit of Ayo and Igoche was a welcome chance to take a step back and gain additional perspective on how we might be able to continue to reduce the use of restrictive practices on our ward. We discussed interventions that had worked in our setting (such as the daily planning exercises) and we also talked about other ideas from the Mental Health Safety Improvement Programme, such as safety crosses.

Since the visit, our work on reducing restrictive practice has continued on a positive trajectory; there were no uses of restrictive practice in March and April 2023. We have also made positive progress on recruitment, and in the longer term we have a move to a new ward to look forward to.

Regardless of the setting or service, quality improvement does not happen in theory or in textbooks. It is about making a real difference to real patients. Sometimes that means we must strive to make things better in challenging situations or with limited resources. I hope that our own progress on Ruby Ward helps to remind staff in similar scenarios that with dedication and access to the support, positive progress is always possible.

Find out more

Please get in touch if you would like to learn more about our work in quality improvement, mental health or patient safety.

Contact us

Transforming Mental Health Care: A Journey to Reduce Restrictive Practices

A sign showing different ward names

Blog

Post Title

Restrictive practices are techniques such as physical restraint, seclusion and rapid tranquilisation used to limit a person’s liberties, movements or freedom to act independently in potentially dangerous situations.

The inappropriate or overuse of restrictive practice in mental health services has been identified as an area of concern in healthcare since at least 2015, and our ongoing work to reduce restrictive practices was highlighted as part of our celebration of World Patient Safety Day in September.

Following on from her visit to an acute female psychiatric ward in August, HIN Patient Safety Project Manager Ayobola Chike-Michael visited Tolworth Hospital’s Jasmines Ward in South West London to see how they are working to reduce restrictive practices and create a compassionate and supportive environment for all patients.

In the ever-evolving landscape of mental health care, the Mental Health Safety Improvement Programme has been making significant strides since its inception in 2021. With a strong focus on reducing restrictive practices, the programme aims to reduce occurrences of physical restraints, seclusion, and rapid tranquilisation across participating wards. During my visit to Tolworth Hospital's Jasmines Ward in South West London, I had the opportunity to meet Hannah McCarthy, the new ward manager, and gain valuable insights into their innovative approach to care. The commitment and dedication of the Jasmines Ward staff to create a safe and compassionate environment were evident from the moment I stepped in.

Jasmines ward, a 16-bed mental health ward for older adults presented a unique set of challenges and requirements. A large proportion of the patients on the ward are living with dementia. While incidents of restrictive practices were explained to me as rare due to the frailty and older nature of the patients, the ward manager and her team seem prepared to handle any situation that might arise. The staff focus on providing personalised care, ensuring everyone’s needs were met. One notable practice was the "This is me" profile on the door of each patient, fostering a sense of identity and promoting a person-centered approach acknowledging each individual’s cultural and family background, as well as their interests and achievements.

The success of Jasmines Ward in providing comprehensive care can be attributed to its robust Multidisciplinary Team (MDT). Comprising of doctors, occupational therapists, physiotherapists, a dietician, an activity coordinator, an exercise therapist, the pharmacist and, upon request, visits from a chiropodist. The MDT works seamlessly to address the diverse needs of the patients. This collaborative approach ensures that the care provided is holistic, focusing not only on mental health but on physical wellbeing too.

The team working on Jasmines Ward recognises the importance of maintaining the dignity and pride of their patients, even during moments of potential restraint. Incidences of restrictive practice are handled sensitively, ensuring safety whilst minimising distress.

Like any healthcare setting, Jasmines Ward faces its own set of challenges; ensuring staff have time and are trained to lead on person-centred care remains a priority. To address this issue the ward is actively seeking long-term solutions; a recent recruitment drive has been successful and the ward are expecting the arrival of five new nurses to join the team in the near future. Flexibility with shifts and a focus on work-life balance are expected to create a more sustainable and fulfilling work environment.

The Mental Health Safety Improvement Programme has introduced several tools to monitor and track restrictive practices effectively. One such tool, the safety cross, is a simple visual representation that enables staff to identify patterns at a glance

In addition to their existing use for falls, the ward is encouraged to also implement safety crosses specifically for restrictive practices. This tool has proven invaluable in other participating wards to shape discussions around frequency of restrictive practices, de-escalation techniques, and proactive interventions.

Stepping into Jasmines Ward, I was greeted by a fast-paced atmosphere catering for patients’ needs constantly. Each patient's door bore a simple profile, offering a personal touch that goes a long way in making patients feel comfortable. The ward faces challenges related to the space available, particularly around storage, but despite this the staff remain dedicated to finding solutions and putting patient well-being at the centre of everything they do.

Image of a poem about Jasmines Ward

Jasmines Ward recognises the importance of feedback from service users and their carers. Verbal feedback is consistently positive, and I was shown an example of handwritten feedback that further exemplified the impact of the compassionate care provided.

A poignant poem displayed on the ward about dementia served as a reminder to both staff and visitors about the ongoing need for kindness and empathy towards patients.

Using the poem as an active reminder and not just part of the wallpaper would be part of my advice to pass on. I believe with their multidisciplinary approach, dedication to feedback, and continuous drive for improvement, Jasmines Ward will remain dedicated to reducing restrictive practices.

Find out more

Please get in touch if you would like to learn more about our work in quality improvement, mental health or patient safety.

Contact us